P is for Peanut Butter and Peanut Butter Cups

My dad recently discovered that he is allergic to peanuts, which posed a huge problem.  Most nights, he sits in his chair next to the fireplace, munching on a small bowl of nuts while reading the paper.  Although he trades off between almonds, pistachios, and peanuts, the peanuts were his favorite.  And he had stocked up on peanuts, buying about a pound or two before the holidays, so when I came home for Christmas, I inherited all of them.


So what’s a girl to do when she has peanuts literally spilling out of her pantry?     


Part I: Peanut Butter

Because it isn’t baseball season and I can’t take my peanuts to a game, I needed some way to consume all of these other than snacking on them morning, noon, and night.  Homemade peanut butter seemed like the perfect option.  With so much less sugar than the typical Skippy or Jif, it tasted even better and healthier than those processed varieties!



Homemade Peanut Butter

based on this peanut butter recipe

yields about c. Peanut Butter

I made a small amount to keep it as fresh as possible, but the recipe scales up quite nicely.  Add both the oil and honey in small portions to fit your tastes.  Some people prefer thicker PB and use less oil, but use more to make it more spreadable.

½ c. salted & shelled peanuts

2-3 tsp vegetable or peanut oil

3-4 drops of honey (or more, to taste)

  1. Add peanuts to a food processor and turn it on until the peanuts are a fine powder and begin to clump together.
  2. Add the oil ½ tsp at a time until PB reaches desired consistency.
  3. Taste the PB, and if you want a slightly sweeter taste, add the honey a drop at a time.  Store PB in an airtight container in the refrigerator.

*Note:  Over time, the peanut butter will thicken in the fridge, but just add a little more oil and swirl it around with a knife to make it more spreadable.




Part II: Peanut Butter Cups

Yet I’ll admit it, I’m not the world’s biggest peanut butter fan.  Maybe it’s because I had too much of it when I was a little girl (there were times where I ate it straight from the jar), but I rarely eat any these days.  Because I didn’t want a huge batch sitting in my fridge, and because the guys at work don’t seem to be making their organic PB sandwiches anymore, I needed a recipe that used up all the peanut butter I just made.


One slight problem…  That recipe also had to be something I had never attempted before.  Rules are rules, and I’m not breaking my Alphabet Adventure ones just yet!  That threw out peanut butter cookies, peanut butter brownies, and pasta with a Thai peanut sauce.  And peanut butter pie just wasn’t calling my name.


So I turned to one of my favorite childhood candies—Reese’s.


Two weeks ago, I bought an adorable set of heart-shaped silicon ice cube molds for Valentine’s Day, and they seemed like the perfect size for my peanut butter cups—slightly larger than a mini-Reese’s cup, which meant more deliciousness in every treat without feeling completely guilty from eating the whole thing.  After spraying the molds with nonstick spray, it was really easy to pop out the peanut butter cups since the silicon deforms so easily.



The only problem I encountered with the whole experience was restraining myself from devouring half the batch as soon as they were done.  (They’re that irresistible, I promise!)  To prevent my hips from yelling at me later, I gave the rest to the little kids next door, and if they weren’t in love with me from all the cookies I’d taken over in the previous weeks, they definitely were now!



Peanut Butter Cups

inspired by Chocolate Peanut Butter Cups

yields 12 (according to their recipe)

I adjusted my recipe since my molds were oddly shaped, but I wrote the original measurements here.  Try using a mini-muffin tin or mini-muffin cups if you want smaller PB cups, or use regular-sized muffin tins for an extra big treat.

1 (11.5 oz) bag semi-sweet chocolate chips, divided

1 tbsp butter, divided

1 c. peanut butter

¼ – ½ c. powdered sugar

¼ tsp vanilla

  1. Spray muffin tin with nonstick cooking spray.  Set aside.
  2. In a large microwave-safe bowl, melt half of the chocolate chips and ½ tbsp butter.  Microwave for 30 sec at a time, stirring after each time, until the chocolate is smooth.
  3. Spoon chocolate into the bottom of each muffin cup, and spread it around so it covers the bottom and sides.  It may not stick to the sides, but be sure to coat the bottom really well.
  4. Stick the muffin tin in the freezer for 10-20 minutes while preparing the peanut butter mixture.
  5. In a medium bowl, mix peanut butter, powdered sugar, and vanilla.  Shape into small balls that will fit inside of the muffin cups.
  6. Remove the chocolate-coated muffin tin from the freezer, and place a peanut butter ball in each.  Be sure that the peanut butter does not touch the sides of the muffin cup!
  7. Melt the remaining chocolate and butter in the microwave.  Spoon over the top of each peanut butter ball, being sure to completely fill the sides around the peanut butter.  (Otherwise your PB cups will have holes in the sides!)  Smooth the top as best you can.
  8. Place muffin tin in the freezer for another 10-20 minutes or until chocolate is set.  Place in the refrigerator until ready to serve.




January 16, 2011. Tags: , , , , . Alphabet Adventure.


  1. C. replied:

    Wow! Please tell me that you have some left to share with visitors….These look incredible! You make it look so easy, too.

    • foods for the soul replied:

      Yes, okay, I lied… I knew I’d have some visitors coming soon, so I reserved a couple for them. But every time I open the fridge, it’s so tempting to eat another one!

  2. shinypigeon replied:

    Oh dear….Reese’s I can make at home? DANGER! My stepmum’s birthday present idea done! She loves Reese’s cups!

    • foods for the soul replied:

      Just make sure you give them ALL to her! I guarantee that these will be calling your name even louder than your wonderful Victorian Cake. I hope you enjoy them!

  3. lillagreca replied:

    Oh man…I HAVE to try these…they look incredibly delicious and sooo cute! There are a few birthdays coming up so these will be perfect treats! 🙂

    • foods for the soul replied:

      Thank you! If you make them, I hope you enjoy them. They were gone in a blink of an eye for me!

  4. Laura Rittenhouse replied:

    I use a similar recipe but mine calls for adding some crumbled graham crackers (or digestive biscuits depending on which part of the world you live in) to the sugar and peanut butter mixture. I find this helps with the texture and adds fiber so it’s basically health food !!!

    I also get really tired of dealing with melted chocolate – I’m just not good at it – so I put my peanut butter mixture into a cake pan of some sort and then just spread melted chocolate on top. It is not as tasty as the cups with choc on all sides but takes me less than half the time to make which gives me more time for eating 🙂

    • foods for the soul replied:

      I made these a while ago, but I do recall that some of the recipes I looked at for inspiration called for graham crackers in the PB filling too. And I love your logic about how it turns the candy into health food!!

      I was really tempted to do that when I made homemade butterfinger bars around Halloween! But I just discovered a little trick to making the chocolate more spreadable: add 2-3 teaspoons of vegetable shortening for every 1 cup of chocolate. It worked like a charm for the Valentine marshmallows I just made!

      • Laura Rittenhouse replied:

        I use something called “melts” – I suspect you have them wherever you are (USA?) – and they melt easily and don’t harden or dry out like chocolate bars do, but I wonder if oil (I assume butter works – my oil of choice) would help. I might just have to try it.

        Either way smearing chocolate into a bunch of cups and then topping them is always going to take longer than just ladling it over the top of a sheet. We have a similar sweet tooth weakness but I see I also suffer the sin of laziness that you lack. Well done you (but I still have more time for eating 🙂 )

      • foods for the soul replied:

        We have both chocolate melts and chips here in the US, but melts are supposedly much better for, well, melting! (I haven’t tried yet, mainly because they’re more expensive than the generic Nestle chocolate chips.) I haven’t had as much luck with butter as I have had with shortening or oil, but maybe that’s just me!

        I have the biggest sweet tooth… But as you’ve proven, patience isn’t always a virtue! ;]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

Trackback URI

%d bloggers like this: